The Science Behind Collagen: Separating Fact from Fiction

Collagen stands as the body’s most abundant protein, making up 75-80% of our skin’s composition and holding an important role in everything from skin elasticity to joint health. Yet misconceptions about this vital protein continue to circulate, leaving many confused about its true benefits and limitations. We sat down with Dr Sonal, founder of Complete by Dr SCS, to separate fact from fiction.

Photo credit: Dr SCS

“Think of collagen as the body’s natural scaffolding,” Dr Sonal explains.

As we age, our body’s collagen production naturally slows down. Dr SCS breaks down the science behind this process:

“Around age 30, we begin losing approximately 1% of our collagen annually. It’s not just about wrinkles – this decline impacts our entire physiological system. Environmental factors like sun exposure, pollution, and poor diet can dramatically accelerate this natural process.” 

With collagen’s critical role in our body becoming clearer, and so many collagen products to choose from, Dr Sonal notes that understanding doesn’t end with recognising its importance. 

“Knowledge is only the first step,” she explains. “With the market flooded with options, different celebrities endorsing various supplements, the science is really lost and a lot of it can be just clever marketing. So much of the information out there can be downright confusing.” So, let’s separate the fact from fiction and debunk 10 common myths surrounding collagen supplements.

10 Common Collagen Supplement Myths Debunked

1. All Collagen Supplements Are the Same 

Dr Sonal quickly dispels this misconception: “Collagen is not a one-size-fits-all supplement. We have vegan builders, marine, bovine, and chicken collagens. Each type – I, II, III – serves a unique purpose in the body.” 

She breaks down the distinctions: “Type I collagen is the most abundant collagen in our body, primarily supporting skin, bones, and connective tissues. It’s what gives your skin that plump, youthful appearance. Type II collagen is crucial for cartilage health, making it especially important for joint support. Type III collagen often works alongside Type I, supporting skin and organ structures.” Dr Sonal emphasises the importance of understanding these differences. “Marine collagen, typically Type I, is known to be rich in hydroxyproline, an amino acid critical for skin health. Bovine collagen provides both Type I and III support. Chicken collagen is particularly beneficial for Type II collagen, making it ideal for joint health.” 

She cautions that depending on the effect, it’s important to choose the right type of collagen. “For example, if you’re seeking joint support, a marine collagen supplement may not be the best option. Your targeted outcome should guide your supplement choice.“

1. Collagen Supplements Directly Become Collagen in Your Body 

“This is a misconception,” Dr Sonal explains. “When you consume collagen supplements, your body undergoes a complex biochemical process. These supplements are broken down into peptides and amino acids, which enter the bloodstream and act as biological signalling molecules.” She elaborates, “The body doesn’t directly reinsert these peptides as collagen. Instead, they provide specific signals that stimulate fibroblasts – the cells responsible for producing collagen.” Dr Sonal emphasises the critical role of nutritional co-factors: “Vitamin C is crucial in this process. It acts as a co-enzyme, supporting the hydroxylation of proline and lysine, which are essential for creating stable collagen molecules.“

1. Collagen Supplements Work Instantly 

“Collagen supplementation is not an overnight miracle. Most scientific studies show noticeable changes typically occur after 8-12 weeks of consistent supplementation.Your body needs to go through multiple stages of protein synthesis, cellular signalling, and tissue remodelling so consistency and patience is key,” Dr Sonal emphasises. 

1. Oral Supplements Are Equally Effective as Topical Treatments 

“Oral supplements win, hands down,” she states. “While some people believe topical collagen is just as good, Topical collagen molecules are typically too large to penetrate deep into the skin.“

1. Collagen Supplements Replace the Need for Protein  

“Collagen is not a complete protein,” Dr Sonal explains. “It lacks essential amino acids like tryptophan that our body cannot produce.” She highlights that while collagen supplements can offer targeted benefits for skin, joint, and connective tissue health, they cannot replace a balanced protein intake. These supplements are specialised nutritional tools – excellent for specific wellness goals, but not a protein substitute. Your diet should still include a variety of protein sources to ensure you are getting a completely balanced diet.“

1. More Expensive Means Better Quality 

“Not necessarily,” Dr Sonal explains. “Sometimes big brands with heavy marketing budgets can charge more for products.” 

She emphasises that the key is ensuring you are getting the right type of collagen with essential co-factors like Vitamin C and at the right dose. “Vitamin C is crucial – it’s a critical co-factor in collagen synthesis, essential for the enzymatic reactions that create collagen molecules.” 

Look for products that provide a comprehensive approach to skin health incorporating ingredients like hyaluronic acid, zinc, copper, Vitamin E, biotin that work synergistically to support skin wellness. 

“The most effective supplements provide a holistic approach,” she advises. “Look beyond price for clinically studied ingredients, transparent sourcing, third-party testing, and research-backed concentrations.“

1. Collagen Supplements Work the Same for Everyone  

“Individual responses vary dramatically,” Dr Sonal emphasises. “Factors like age, health, diet, and genetics play crucial roles.” She explains that biological individuality means supplement effectiveness can differ significantly between people. “Your metabolic rate, hormonal balance, existing nutrient levels, and even stress can influence how your body processes and responds to collagen supplements.“

1. Vegans Can’t Take Collagen Supplements 

“Modern nutrition science has evolved,” states Dr Sonal. “Vecollal, for example, is a biomimetic collagen builder, a groundbreaking plant-based solution that’s revolutionising supplement options for vegans. Unlike traditional supplements derived from marine or animal sources, Vecollal uses advanced biomimetic technology to provide amino acids that precisely match human collagen structures.“

1. Collagen Supplements Are Only for Skin and Beauty 

“Collagen’s role extends far beyond skin deep,” Dr Sonal explains. “It’s a crucial protein that plays a fundamental role in multiple bodily systems.” She breaks down the comprehensive benefits beyond aesthetics; “Collagen is essential for joint health, providing structural support for cartilage integrity. In bone health, it provides the matrix that gives bones strength and flexibility. For muscles, it supports tissue repair and growth. In the gut, amino acids like glycine support the digestive tract’s protective lining.“

1. You Can’t Get Collagen from Food 

“Supplements are convenient, but don’t underestimate whole foods,” Dr Sonal explains. “Your diet can significantly influence collagen production.” She highlights key sources; “Bone broth is rich in collagen-supporting amino acids. Fish with edible bones, chicken, and egg whites provide essential proteins. Vitamin C-rich foods like citrus fruits and bell peppers are critical for converting amino acids into collagen molecules The key is a varied, nutrient-dense diet. Supplements can be valuable, but they shouldn’t replace whole-food nutrition.“

For evidence-based skincare insights and nutrition tips, explore more at www.completebydrscs.com

Join our growing community of skin science enthusiasts:

Instagram: @completebydrscs

TikTok: @completebydrscs

Facebook: Complete by Dr SCS

Pinterest: @completebydrscs

LinkedIn: Complete by Dr SCS